Ask McEnearney: What’s Involved in Buying or Selling a Very, Very Old Home?

This week’s Q&A column is sponsored and written by Ann Duff of McEnearney Associates Realtors®, the leading real estate firm in Alexandria. To learn more about this article and relevant Alexandria market news, contact Ann at 703-965- 8700 or email [email protected]. You may also submit your questions to McEnearney Associates via email for response in future columns.

Question: Dig deeply, literally… How different can that be? Ask your realtor and learn from our experiences as you dip your toes into historic property ownership.

Answer: Just last week, while homebound as we all are, I surrounded my worktable with stacks of books to synopsize the history of a new listing. All to bring the past alive… this was for Alexandria, Virginia’s oldest property constructed, which started in 1749. More than just the date, stories and facts came together using source books and journals — “The Alexandria Chronicle,” Seaport in Virginia, written in 1949, “Historic Preservation,” and The Alexandria Waterfront Forum: Birth and Rebirth, dated 1983, as well as other fine writings.

Resulting in a rollicking read, the home’s past came to life. Along with photos of the John Dalton house through the last century and a half, we learned of its original ice well found in the lower level where archeologists excavated sixteen feet down finding old bottles and metal as well as its unique carved stone balusters in the garden.

This drew the ‘hidden historian’ out of many potential home buyers who visited and led to many spirited conversations, with the trading of names of other researchers and authors and a look into the Founding Fathers of Alexandria.

Listing agents should share the stories and do this deep research, in my opinion. We may not create Hamilton-worthy drama and song, but, where possible, find out more about one of our many, many historic homes so that the richness or even daily life vignettes carry forward to the next owners and their neighbors.

Not provided by the listing company? Buyer’s agents can do the same background work, even after the contract is signed — what could be better a house-warming gift?

While at it, head to the courthouse and check the deeds, recorded easements, subdivisions and boundaries, so that everything impacting ownership, taxes, prohibition against or permissibility of building a pool or expanding can be explained. Guidelines from Alexandria’s or D.C.’s Boards of Architectural Review will be appreciated, too, so that future work maintains the historic “fabric.” No aluminum siding or defilement of old brick structures is allowed, for instance.

The Library of Congress and local libraries can be a wealth of knowledge and, in the case of the branch manager at Local History and Special Collections Branch of the Alexandria Library, there was kindness shown in helping me with virtual research necessary with the current lockdown.

Scanning the grounds with a metal detector is another way of digging up the past — old coins, clay pipes, round balls for muzzle-loading guns. Many homes have displays of their findings and tend to convey them with any sale. There is even a home where a painting of the original silversmith owner has been deeded for years and years along with the brick and mortar of the structure.

Knowing the way homes were first built here in the colonies is helpful, too. Even the well-to-do, did not have many suits of clothing or dresses, so the closets were very shallow with hooks, certainly not wide to fit hangers. Most homes had or shared outdoor cooking facilities, since kitchens were a troublesome source of fires, and indoor plumbing didn’t become common until well into the 1800s. Tall ceilings were a sign of wealth and many artisans, lawyers and businesses plied their trades on the first floor of the residences while living upstairs.

Look at the changes made over the years to accommodate today’s lifestyle. Smart sellers keep the gracious touches of old and work walk-in closets, bathrooms and generous kitchens into the structure’s spaces. While there are no restrictions in Alexandria regarding paint color, it is a time-honored tradition to work with neighbors to create a pleasing palate or to plan for the display of flags and lighted front lanterns along the block.

Love original wood floors, wavy old pressed glass, showing off real or imagined ancestors with a display of oil portraits, bookcases and more? Want to walk in your own sheltered garden shaded by a canopy of trees?

Just imagine having the opportunity to walk in early footsteps, listen to the walls talk, feel the beauty of singular craftsmanship. All it takes is a little digging!

Ann Duff — Your positive advantage for Residential and Commercial properties throughout the area. Experience and Energy, Negotiations and Knowledge — All with a splash of fun! Let’s Get Busy!

If you would like a question answered in our weekly column or to set up an appointment with one of our Associates, please email: [email protected] or call 703-549-9292.

McEnearney Associates Realtors®, 109 S. Pitt Street, Alexandria, VA 22314. Equal Housing Opportunity. #WeAreAlexandria

Recent Stories

The City of Alexandria is planning to work with a local non-profit to quantify the demand for after-school activities. At an upcoming City Council meeting on Wednesday, Sept. 28, the…

The City of Alexandria is looking into building a pedestrian bridge over I-395 to connect the Landmark Mall site to neighborhoods west of the highway. Last week, the Transportation Commission…

Alexandria City Public Schools is entering a tricky budget season. As student enrollment and expenditure increases outpace revenue, ACPS faces a $12 million deficit in the run up to the…

The sequel to one of the highest-grossing films of all time is coming early to Alexandria. City Councilman John Taylor Chapman’s Manumission Tour Company has once again teamed with other…

Are you tired of going to the gym? It might be the crowds, the locker room, waiting on equipment or the time it takes to commute to the gym.

Having a personal trainer come to your home will keep you accountable, save you time and allow you to workout in the comfort of your own home.

Skip the hassle of the gym and try our in-home personal training service.

Our services are reasonably priced, convenient, effective and are risk free.

Read More

Submit your own Community Post here.

At Nova Fencing Club, the beginner fencing classes are designed for students of all levels – including students who have never fenced before.

If you’re looking for a fun physical activity that improves your fitness, critical thinking and rapid decision making skills then come join us!

There’s no better time than now to give us a try – and take part in one of the fastest growing sports. Our highly educated, professional coaching staff includes Virginia’s only Maitre d’Armes, a member of USA Fencing’s coaching team, former members of the USA National Team, and our Head Coach, who has produced national champions.

Register for either our Youth Beginner Fencing Classes (7-12) or our Teen & Adult Beginner Fencing Classes (13 to Adult) and become a part of the club that champions call home.

Submit your own Community Post here.

Think BIG! About the Future of Movement

Join the City of Alexandria and Arlington County’s Initiative to Rethink Energy at our first ever electric vehicle (EV) and sustainable technologies showcase! Get inspired by seeing a variety of electric cars, scooters, bikes, motorcycles, police cars, buses, trucks and

Between Home and the Front: Book Talk and Signing

Join the Smithsonian’s National Postal Museum on Zoom or in person at the museum for a special book talk with the curators behind Between Home and the Front: Civil War Letters of the Walters Family. A book signing will be


Subscribe to our mailing list