News

The Garden owners settle case with landlord, will stay in Del Ray five more years

The owners of a popular beer garden in Del Ray have reached a settlement agreement with their landlord and will be staying for five more years.

Jeremy Barber and Justus Frank, the owners of The Garden (1503 Mount Vernon Avenue), spent tens of thousands of dollars in court over the last year against their landlord, Twenty-Third Street Corridor LLC, for allegedly not honoring a five-year renewal option on their lease, which expired in November 2025.

Barber got a call from his attorney in late October that their landlord wanted to settle.

“We ended up settling and getting an additional five years, which is what we were owed,” Barber told ALXnow. “Yes, we are paying a little bit more rent, but we’re happy that we were able to work a deal out.”

Barber and Frank previously told ALXnow that they tried to buy the 5,300-square-foot property. After the deal fell through, they said, the landlord spent the next seven months trying to evict them with default notices on property repair issues. In September 2025, two months before their lease was set to expire, the landlord listed the property for rent. Barber and Frank then sued, and the landlord filed an eviction lawsuit.

Stratis and Georgia Voutsas are the principals of Twenty-Third Street Corridor LLC. ALXnow has reached out to their attorney, Mark P. Friedlander, Jr. for comment.

Georgia Voustas previously told ALXnow that Barber and Frank let the property go into disrepair, and that the rent wasn’t raised for five years. They later dropped their lawsuit.

“They violated the terms of our lease, allowed the place to fall into disrepair to the point where it even threatened the health of the patrons,” Voustas previously said. “Then they tried to shake us down for tens of thousands of dollars to force us to make the repairs that they were responsible for under a triple net lease.”

The Del Ray Business Association celebrated the news of The Garden staying.

“We are THRILLED that @thegardendelray is here to stay,” the association posted on Facebook. “Join Jeremy, Justus, Mauricio and the entire team for a celebration on Saturday, Nov. 21 as they toast to another five years (at least!) in Del Ray.”

Barber said that there will be a party at The Garden on Nov. 21, from noon until the last customer leaves.

“We’ve got live music, food and drink specials and we’re going to preview that we’re going to keep a covered space in the back open all winter for the first time since we’ve been here,” Barber said. “I can’t even express to you how how much the community backed us, fought with us, supported us and kept coming in. It was really cool, and that’s why we’re going to throw this party on the 21st as a big thank you to all of them.”

The Garden opened in January 2019. Barber and Frank also own Mill Street Draft Garden in Occoquan, and they employ about 30 people between the two businesses.

“We’re here through the end of 2031, and we’re paying an escalated rent over the next five years, but nothing that was enough for us to go, ‘That’s crazy,'” Barber said. “I think at the end of the day, both sides are extremely happy with the outcome.”

About the Author

  • James Cullum

    Reporter James Cullum has spent nearly 20 years covering Northern Virginia. He began working with ALXnow in 2020, and has covered every story under the sun for the publication, from investigative stories to features and photo galleries. His work includes coverage of national and international situations, as well as from the White House, Capitol, Pentagon, Supreme Court and State Department. He's covered protests and riots throughout the U.S. (including the Jan. 6 riot at the U.S. Capitol), in addition to earthquake-ridden Haiti, Western Sahara in North Africa and war-torn South Sudan. He has photographed presidents and other world leaders, celebrities and famous musicians, and excels under pressure.