Fans of Van Leeuwen Ice Cream won’t have to travel to Arlington anymore to get their fix. The company recently filed an administrative special use permit (DSUP) application with the city to open a location in Old Town.
The New York City ice cream shop wants to open at 400 King Street, next door to the Alexandrian Old Town Hotel and Southern restaurant King & Rye. Proposed hours would be 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. seven days a week, and the business expects between 150 and 250 daily customers, according to the SUP. The last day for public comments on the proposal is Aug. 21.
Van Leeuwen says in its application that improvements to the property include:
- New interior partitions to define back of house and sales area functions
- New light fixtures
- An electrical, mechanical and plumbing system
- New finished, fixtures, millwork and equipment, including a 3-compartment sink, grease trap, refrigerators and freezers
The DSUP also said that no ice cream will be made on-site.

News of the news shop shouldn’t come as too much of a surprise. In March, the building’s owner, AB/FH Alexandrian Hotel Owner LLC, submitted paperwork to demolish existing vacant tenant space and add new ADA-compliant entrances. In that application, renderings from prospective tenants were also included in the submission from architect Pames Pandula of K+P Architects. Those renderings show the exterior of a vibrant Van Leeuwen ice cream shop next to where King & Rye is currently located and a Life Alive Organic Cafe in an empty space formerly occupied by Long and Fosters Realtors.
The company was founded as an ice cream truck in New York City in 2008, according to the Van Leeuwen website. It’s headquartered in Brooklyn, and now has more than 50 locations across the country.
The shop will face stiff competition. In case you missed it, Forbes listed Alexandria as the ice cream cone capital of the U.S. in 2019.
Below is a list of ice cream shops in Alexandria.
- The Creamery (110 King Street)
- Pop’s Old Fashioned Ice Cream Co. (109 King Street)
- Kilwins Ice Cream (212 King Street)
- The Crazy Mason Milkshake Bar (716 King Street)
- Pitango Gelato & Coffee (115 S. Union Street)
- Casa Rosada Artisan Gelato (111 S. Payne Street)
- Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams (102 S. Patrick Street)
- Goodies Frozen Custard & Treats (200 Commerce Street)
- Dolci Gelati (107 N Fairfax Street)
- Ben & Jerry’s (103 S. Union Street)
- Lil’ Cakes and Creamery (1014 Madison Street)
- The Dairy Godmother (2312 Mount Vernon Avenue)
- Cold Stone Creamery (239 Hoffman Street)
- Baskin-Robbins (3325 Richmond Highway and 1701 Centre Plaza)