News

Tough decisions ahead as officials stare down $370M ACPS capital plan

Challenged by facility demands and multimillion-dollar shortfalls, Alexandria’s City Council and School Board acknowledged Monday night (Nov. 16) that there will be tough budget decisions in the days ahead.

Councilman John Taylor Chapman said that it will be hard for the city to commit to more than $200 million in the Alexandria City Public Schools 10-year Capital Improvement Program budget, as the City Council and School Board whittle down Acting Superintendent Grace Taylor’s $370.6 million request. The capital proposal goes over the city’s guidance by more than $186 million. Chapman was joined at Monday’s Joint City Council/School Board CIP budget work session by city and schools staff.

Chapman said that the city needs to find more money, and that City Manager Jim Parajon is being realistic about the city’s finances. ACPS takes up nearly 30% of the city’s budget and also faces a $17 million budget gap.

“We are going to have to figure out if it’s tax increase,” Chapman said. “I think the manager is being, I wouldn’t say conservative, but I think he’s being realistic about what if we don’t make additional money, where do things stand? And so he has to operate from that baseline, and then I think it’s on council to make the decisions about tax rate and other things, other tools to try to make up the difference.”

The proposed ACPS Capital Improvement Program summary (via ACPS)

Parajon said that there are hard trade-offs between keeping programs operating or funding capital projects.

“Now we’re in a situation where we have a couple large city projects, the City Hall project, a major flooding project,” Parajon said. “Those are going to eat up capital. So I think it kind of goes like this, depending upon what is the community’s strongest need, and that’s how we try to do that.”

The bodies also looked at eight middle school capacity scenarios, with the proposed conversions of Jefferson-Houston PreK-8 School into a middle school and Patrick Henry K-8 School into an elementary school.

SEE: As enrollment declines, councilman asks if ACPS should pause capacity expansion projects

ACPS middle school capacity scenarios (via ACPS)

At the meeting, the city laid out the following questions:

  • How is enrollment changing, and what does it mean for school capacity and utilization over the next 10 years?
  • How much capital capacity do we have under the City Manager’s guidance, and which options fit within it?
  • How do we address middle school capacity needs, over 110% utilization in FY28–FY29, as enrollment shifts between elementary and middle school grades?
  • Which approach (conversion, new construction or modulars) provides the best long-term value for students and City of Alexandria residents?

“We will not be able to afford all of the improvements that are necessary to keep every single building up, which means that we’ve got to make that the council and the school board need to make certain decisions about how to approach those things later in the fiscal years,” Parajon said. “I think we’re pretty solid for the next three to five years.”

ACPS middle school capacity models (via ACPS)

Mayor Alyia Gaskins said that the city needs to consider its public-private partnerships.

“I think there are some significant maintenance needs across the city that have been put off for far too long,” Gaskins said. “If there’s a way to think about even private-public partnerships that benefit the schools and the city, I really think we should not lose sight of potentially what that funding could be and if there are innovative models in the private sector that could accelerate some of those investments.”

Councilwoman Sandy Marks recommended that School Board and City Council members should work in groups of two-by-twos on the budget, an idea was widely accepted at the meeting.

“It seems to me that it might be worth it to organize some two-by-twos for School Board and potentially also Council, but definitely for School Board members with some city staff to exchange ideas, to learn, and to build some relationships across the bodies and across the staff, so that we could be more on the same page and sort of level-set,” Marks said. “I know with Acting Superintendent Taylor that there is a big shift that will be happening in the school system soon, and so this might be a really great precedent to set moving forward for how we operate together.”

School Board Chair Chris Harris said that School Board Members and Council will participate in two-by-two meetings to determine the structure of a new working group between the bodies.

“The School Board will provide an update to the community once the structure has been determined,” Harris said in a statement to ALXnow.

Taylor, who will be replaced by incoming Superintendent Jharrett Bryantt on Feb. 1, 2027,  agreed with Marks that more work with the School Board on the budget is needed.

“You have my commitment during the transition,” Taylor said. “Our new superintendent, Dr. Bryant, comes on Feb. 1, and I will be here to kind of catch him up to speed, and he’s off and running. But definitely, you have our our the commitment from our staff.”

The City manager’s guidance for the ACPS 10-year Capital Improvement Program (via ACPS)

Upcoming capital budget discussions

The School Board will conduct the following meetings this fall:

  • Dec. 1 — School Board CIP Budget Work Session #2
  • Dec. 8 — School Board CIP Add/Delete Work Session #1
  • Dec. 10 — School Board CIP Add/Delete Work Session
  • Dec. 17 — Regular School Board Meeting: Adoption of the FY 2028-2037 CIP Budget

About the Author

  • James Cullum

    Reporter James Cullum has spent nearly 20 years covering Northern Virginia. He began working with ALXnow in 2020, and has covered every story under the sun for the publication, from investigative stories to features and photo galleries. His work includes coverage of national and international situations, as well as from the White House, Capitol, Pentagon, Supreme Court and State Department. He's covered protests and riots throughout the U.S. (including the Jan. 6 riot at the U.S. Capitol), in addition to earthquake-ridden Haiti, Western Sahara in North Africa and war-torn South Sudan. He has photographed presidents and other world leaders, celebrities and famous musicians, and excels under pressure.